Quantitative ultrasound assessment of bone quality – time for a new paradigm — ASN Events

Quantitative ultrasound assessment of bone quality – time for a new paradigm (#10)

Christian Langton 1
  1. Institute of Health and Biomedical Innovation, Queensland University of Technology, Kelvin Grove, QLD, Australia

The ability of quantitative ultrasound (QUS) to discriminate osteoporotic fracture subjects was first demonstrated over 30 years ago [1]; yet it is still frequently referred to as ‘an interesting and promising technique’. A primary factor impeding utility in routine diagnosis and management of osteoporosis has been the inability to transpose QUS parameters into meaningful measures of bone quantity and bone quality. Whereas X-ray photons are significantly attenuated by calcium atoms, from which we may derive bone quantity estimates of areal and volumetric bone mineral density (BMD); ultrasound wave propagation is dependent upon relatively macroscopic properties of both bone quantity and bone quality, particularly structure. 

A new concept to describe ultrasound propagation through complex composites such as cancellous bone has recently been described [2]. It considers an array of parallel sonic rays, whose individual transit time is dependent upon the proportion of bone tissue and marrow encountered. Variation in transit time results in phase-interference induced ultrasound attenuation. A transit time spectrum (TTS) may be derived, from which bone volume fraction may be estimated [3].  Recent in-vitro work has demonstrated that the TTS may also provide a measure of cancellous bone structure; by combining TTS parameters related to both bone quantity and quality, a high correlation with mechanical integrity was observed.

It is anticipated that the transit time spectral concept will provide an accurate estimate of BMD, and hence facilitate implementation of WHO osteoporosis/osteopenia criteria, as well as predicting osteoporotic fracture risk.

  1. Langton C M, Palmer S B, Porter R W; 1984; The measurement of broadband ultrasonic attenuation in cancellous bone; Eng. in Med., 13(2), 89-91; 742 citations
  2. Langton C M; 2011; 25th Anniversary of BUA for the Assessment of Osteoporosis - Time for a New Paradigm?; Engineering in Medicine; 225 (2),113-125
  3. Wille M-L and Langton C M; 2016; Solid Volume Fraction Estimation of Bone:Marrow Replica Models using Ultrasound Transit Time Spectroscopy; Ultrasonics; 65; 329-337